Trader Joes’s fall snacks, ranked

We rounded up five Trader Joes fall snacks to give ratings on three categories. (Aryan Kawatra)

As the leaves turn brown and the air gets cooler, I don’t get excited for “sweater weather” or the holidays. Instead, I count down the days until the fall products line the Trader Joe’s shelves. From the polarizing (but delicious) Butternut Squash Mac and Cheese to the Gluten Free Pumpkin Streusel Muffins, the umbrella of fall items at Trader Joe’s contains limitless possibilities. Whether you have a sweet tooth or prefer saltier nibbles, Trader Joe’s is sure to have a fall snack item for you.

I taste-tested five of the most popular fall snacks at Trader Joe’s — snacks that I’ve never tried before — and gave them each a rating based on flavor, appearance and texture.

Halloween Joe Joe’s Cookies

(Aryan Kawatra)

The Halloween Joe Joe’s Cookies were identical to the classic Joe Joe’s, aside from the pumpkin-faced cookies and annatto-infused cream that give them a clever “costumed” appearance. These miniature chocolate sandwich cookies had a hefty layer of orange cream spilling over the sides of the two thin and crunchy chocolate biscuits sandwiching the filling.

Within the first bite of this crunchy sandwich, the rich sweetness of the cream blended perfectly with the semi-sweet cookies, making for a chocolatey and pleasant bite. Easy to eat and plentiful in each box, the Halloween Joe Joe’s Cookies are definitely an on-theme snack to buy during the fall months.

Flavor: 9/10
Appearance: 9/10
Texture: 9/10
Overall: 27/30

(Aryan Kawatra)

Pumpkin Spice Batons

(Aryan Kawatra)

My expectations were high for these crispy wafers filled with pumpkin spice cream, so when I took a bite and was met with no unique autumn flavors, it’s safe to say I was disappointed. Instead of a warm and comforting taste, the “pumpkin spice” filling had an artificial note that was not masked by the lightly sweetened wafer.

It’s worth noting, though, that the batons had a perfect light and crispy texture. Though their flavor was nothing extraordinary, these are a fun and simple snack to eat on-the-go. 

Flavor: 5/10
Appearance: 9/10
Texture: 10/10
Overall: 24/30

Teeny Tiny Apple Pies

(Aryan Kawatra)

These miniature pies had a promising homemade appearance. Clumps of sugary goodness covered the top of the pie, forming a layer so dense that the gooey apple inside was barely peeking through. For this reason, I was disappointed when, upon taking my first bite, a gluey texture and weak apple flavor were all that came through, with no hint of the sweet, rich and tart homemade flavors I was hoping for.

If these pies had been warm and baked longer, they would have received a higher ranking. In the end, the extra-chewy dough and lack of a strong flavor combined to make the Teeny Tiny Apple Pies an unfavorable item to purchase. However, paired with a scoop of vanilla ice cream and warmed in the oven or microwave, I’m sure these pies would be elevated to the next level.

Flavor: 4/10
Appearance: 6/10
Texture: 3/10
Overall: 12/30

Ghosts & Bats Potato Snacks

(Aryan Kawatra)

These ultra-thin potato chips in the shapes of ghosts and bats were nearly impossible to stop eating. From the airy crunch of the chips to the perfect hint of saltiness that kept me reaching for more, these potato crisps attained the perfect balance of snackability and taste.

The chips lacked the typical oiliness of a potato chip, which made them all the more pleasant to eat. The only aspect hindering the enjoyability of these snacks was the lack of a strong potato flavor: without the word potato in the name, it would be difficult to pinpoint what these chips were made of.

Flavor: 8/10
Appearance: 8/10
Texture: 10/10
Overall: 26/30 

(Aryan Kawatra)

Pumpkin Spice Mini Sheet Cake

(Aryan Kawatra)

Upon lifting the plastic lid off of the box, I was greeted by a rectangular cake with a thick layer of cream cheese frosting. The cake was a dark, golden brown color, and the interior was filled with the holes and bubbles of a perfectly-baked dessert. 

As I tasted the item, I noticed that the moist cake was laden with notes of cinnamon, ginger and (shockingly) pumpkin. It was perfectly airy, with thick frosting that meshed well with the fluffy and light texture of the cake itself.

However, this frosting also posed the cake’s biggest flaw — it was almost too sweet, and the cream cheese flavor had an artificial hint to it. 

Aside from the frosting, this cake was perfect to me. It contains all the spice-heavy, warm flavors that I seek out in a fall baked good. I would recommend this cake to anyone who wants something delicious and actually pumpkin-flavored to eat.

Flavor: 9/10
Appearance: 10/10
Texture: 10/10
Overall: 29/30

(Aryan Kawatra)

My Verdict

All-in-all, the Mini Pumpkin Sheet Cake took the cake for the best fall item at Trader Joe’s, followed closely by the Halloween Joe Joe’s. The Ghosts & Bats secured the middle spot, as they are a solid snack but do not capture the essence of fall as well as any of the other snacks do. The Pumpkin Spice Batons are a respectable fourth-place item, which leaves the Mini Apple Pies to procure the spot of my least favorite fall Trader Joe’s item. At the end of the day, there is an item here for everyone, whether you’re in the mood to snack on something salty or eat an entire mini cake.

Leave a Reply

Related